The Seven Stages in Tumble Polishing Stones: The Selected 40 Stones

The first Post in this series described Stage One, Stone Collection. To illustrate the next six stages in the tumble polishing of stones, I decided to select 40 of the stones I had collected at Riverton in early November. I chose a range of sizes, colour and quality. The following are photos of all 40 stones, first of all how they appear dry and then how they appear wet. This demonstrates how wetness brings out colours and patterns much better.

Stones 1 to 5:

1st 4 dry1st 4 wet

It will be interesting to see how much of each stone is worn away throughout the tumbling process. Stone 1 (far left) is about 8 cms long and about 5 cms wide at its widest point (using the graph paper it is lying on in the “dry” pic above).  Stone 3 is about 6 cms long and 4.5 cms wide, while Stone 5 (far right) is just over 7 cms long and is 3 cms wide. I think that Stone 1 is of volcanic origin, as it has small specks in it that would have originally be gaseous pockets, and will turn out to be similar to another Riverton stone I polished recently (below). 

DSC07257

Stone 2 is also probably volcanic in origin, having similar specks. Stone 4 looks like a conglomerate (which simply means it consists of small rounded stones cemented together in a fine-grained matrix). [As its surface became clearer after some tumbling, I decided Stone 4 is in fact a breccia, composed of angular fragments.] Stones 1, 2, 4 and 5 would be too big for a 3lb barrel.

Stones 6 to 10:

2nd 4 dry2nd 4 wet

These are progressively smaller, with Stone 6 (far left) being about 6 cms long and 4 cms wide. Stone 7 could be argillite (a kind of mudstone subjected to heat and pressure) or epidote (green coloured rock), Stone 9 is a breccia (which simply means it consists of broken fragments of very small stones) and Stone 10 is another conglomerate. 

Stones 11 to 15:

3rd 4 dry3rd 4 wet

The progression to smaller continues. Stone 14 (second from right) is a pink granite that is just over 5 cms long and is just under 4 cms wide at the top. Stone 12, a quartzite, demonstrates how wetness brings out the nature of a stone. Dry, it appears a bland white. Wet, patterns of colour in a strand-like formation become visible with a subtle depth being present. Stone 15, which could be argillite, has an interesting wavy band of white silica.  

Stones 16 to 20:

4th 4 dry4th 4 wet

Stones 18 and 19, both about 4 cms long, are potentially quite spectacular. Stone 18 has a number of different coloured bands. Stone 19 contains contrasting black and white sections, and it will be interesting to see if these erode or polish differently.

Stones 21 to 25:

5th 4 dry5th 4 wet

Stone 25 (far right) has some interesting bands that will be brought out by the tumble polishing, but Stone 22 (second from left) may turn out to be even more interesting. The white on the surface of Stone 23 (middle) may be worn away in the process it goes through, but there may be interesting patterns underneath.

Stones 26 to 30:

6th 4 dry6th 4 wet

Stone 26 (far left) is 3.5 cms long and just over 2.5 cms wide. Its two-toned character attracted my eye on the beach. White is a colour that always stands out on the beach too, Stone 27 being a white quartz with a couple of dark intrusions.

Stones 31 to 35:

7th 4 dry7th 4 wet

Stone 31 (left) may be part-jasper, and Stones 32 and 34 are probably varieties of jasper. Stone 33 has interesting reddish protuberance that caught my eye on the beach. Stone 35, white quartz, is 3 cms long and just under 2 cms wide. 

Stones 36 to 40:

8th 4 dry8th 4 wet

The smallest stone, Stone 40 (far right), jasper, is 2 cms by 1.5 cms. Up to 20% of a stone may be worn away by the tumbling process so not much may be left of this at the end. However, small stones are good in a tumbling barrel as they “carry” the grit and polish to the larger stones.   

I weighed the 40 stones on a set of scales I have in my stone tumbling shed. First placing the empty container on the scales, I moved the setting back to zero so that only the weight of the stones would be indicated = 1605 grams (3.5lbs).

a - weigh in

I will weigh the stones after each stage of tumbling to see how much of them is worn away. 

The next Post in this series describes Stage Two of tumble polishing, the 100 grit tumble.

The Seven Stages in Tumble Polishing Stones: Stage One, Stone Collection, Riverton, 2-6 November 2017

NOTE: March 2021. Due to changes in the supply of grit and polish, plus a few other things, there are now six stages that I recommend instead of seven. The details are in UP-DATE OF “The Seven Stages in Tumble Polishing Stones” – One Less Stage. However, there are many useful practical suggestions in this original series so I have decided to leave it basically unchanged.

There are seven stages in the tumble polishing of stones. The first stage is acquiring the rough stones, stones of the right shape and condition and colour that show good promise for polishing. (Note that nearly all other accounts of tumble polishing don’t include stone collection as a stage.) Stage Two, for me, is tumbling the stones for about a week in 100 mesh silicon carbide grit, then tumbling them in a soap wash for a few hours. In Stage Three I repeat this process, using 220 mesh silicon carbide grit, while Stage Four is the same procedure with 320 silicon carbide grit. At this point, the stones should be shaped and smooth enough to begin actual polishing. I then use two polishing stages. Stage Five involves tumbling the stones in a tin oxide “Pre-Polish” powder (five microns in size) for three to five days, followed again by a few hours soap tumble. Stage Six is the “Pro-Polish” tumble, using tin oxide powder of one micron size, for at least one week. The final stage, Stage Seven, is a “burnishing” tumble for a week in borax. At every stage, stones are individually examined and may be set aside to repeat a stage or, more rarely, even skip a stage.

I emphasise that these seven stages describe what I normally do. However, I often start tumbling a newly collected smooth beach stone at Stage Four. Note that other tumble polishers often use different grits and polishes in different  ways. What I am describing is what I do and how I do it.

For me, Stage One, stone collection, usually involves spending time on beaches, head down, occasionally bending over to pick up a stone worthy of collection. The best way to decide if a stone is worth polishing is to view it wet, so I often walk along the sea edge where the waves roll in then die out as they wash over the sand and stones. I will often take a promising dry stone to the wave edge so it can be wettened to bring out its colour. If it is raining, all the better as I then do not need to keep on checking for the next big wave that may wash in and wet my feet.

I often wear gumboots but sometimes even those are overwhelmed by an unexpectedly larger or more energetic wave.

imagejpeg_0001
Wringing out wet socks after a wave swept in further than expected and overwhelmed my gumboots. Bag of collected rocks beside me. This is at Orepuki (Gemstone Beach) near Riverton, 4 November 2017. Photo taken by Helen Hannah.

Clothes worn for stone collecting: usually warm clothes as beaches are often windy; gumboots or jandals depending on temperature; cap (if sunny) or woolen hat (if cold and cloudy); light waterproof coat and waterproof over-trousers if weather is wet. 

Equipment used for stone collecting: small backpack to carry drinking water, food, camera, plastic collecting bags, and collected stones.

Kinds of stones worth collecting: those with interesting colours and patterns; the smoother the better; the harder the better; the more slippery the better; with a minimum of cracks and pits and jagged edges; not too big (as the tumble barrels are small) and not too small (as the polishing process wears away a proportion of the stone). When wet, you can see a stone’s colours but the cracks and pits in it are not so easy to see. When dry, the cracks and pits can be more easily seen, but the stone will look dull.

I mainly collect beach stones and river stones. They have the advantage of being smoother and more easily identifiable than stones or rocks found anywhere else. They are easier to tumble polish because their jagged edges have already been worn off.

Some beaches have just a scattering of stones along the sand – it is still possible to find some very good specimens here as you stroll along.

 Other beaches have masses of stones. Sometimes a collector need just stand or sit there to find many good specimens.

Stone collecting means that you visit interesting and scenic places. During this trip to Riverton, I appreciated patterns on the sand at Henderson Bay, bird wildlife at the Back Beach, and the rising of a full moon over Taramea Bay.

Once the stones are collected, they need to be taken home. Sometimes, such as when I am travelling by aeroplane, that means putting them in a plastic container and then posting them. When I went to post some to my home in the North Island at a Post Shop in Gore, I was asked by the assistant, “Don’t they have any stones up there?” “Not like these, no,” I replied, and I showed her some polished ones I had in my pocket. She was amazed at their beauty and understood why I was doing such a strange thing as mailing what looked like ordinary everyday stones across the country. 

The next stage in tumble polishing happens at home after I unpack the collected stones or after the Postie has delivered those I earlier put in the mail. Stage Two involves tumbling rough stones in water and a low grade abrasive grit. In the next Post I will describe the Riverton stones selected to go through the stages of tumbling to illustrate this series. I will then look at their first tumble, in The Seven Stages in Tumble Polishing Stones: Stage Two, 100 Grit Tumble, 15-25 November 2017.

How Stones Tumble in a Rotary Tumbler

RockTumbler.com has a great video showing what happens inside a rotary tumbler. The clip is only 44 seconds long but it graphically demonstrates what happens if the barrel is too full and if it is not full enough. It’s conclusions are:

Barrel Too Full = No Tumbling Action 

Barrel Not Full Enough = Damaged Stones 

Barrel 1/2 to 2/3 Full = Great Tumbling Action

The Best Rock Tumbling Book Around – “Modern Rock Tumbling” by Steve Hart (2008)

In 2008, Steve Hart published “Modern Rock Tumbling”, sub-titled “The only complete and up-to-date guide to tumble polishing rocks and stones”. It has just become available as an e-book. I wholeheartedly endorse it. The author, from California, is a mechanical engineer in the mining industry and has a wealth of experience as a home-based rock polisher using both rotary and vibratory methods.  He has a small web-based company, The Little Red Store, started in 2008, which not only sells Steve’s book and rock tumbling equipment and material but also contains some very useful technical tips for those new to modern rock tumbling.

I purchased Steve’s book from Fire Mountain Gems, a US beading and jewelry supply company, as I was not at that stage aware of Steve’s own website. I had seen the book referred to on RockTumbler.com where it is stated: “We have read every book about tumbling that we could find. From that reading we have found that there are only a few books that explain tumbling with great clarity and genuine knowledge. Of those, we believe that Steve Hart has produced the best one. It explains the tumbling process completely and provides enough detail that you should produce excellent results if you follow his instructions.”

“Modern Rock Tumbling” measures 23 cm by 15 cm and is 96 pages long. It sells for about US$25 and is great value-for-money. It is very well organised and the writing is clear and good humoured. There are colourful photographs illustrating key parts of the tumbling process. 

The best attributes of this book are: it is very practical, dealing with the details of rock tumbling, and all advice is based on the author’s wealth of experience; it explains technical issues when of relevance, and Steve’s background in mining is useful here as is the range of people he has consulted in the preparation of the book; and it presents the various options available to the rock tumbler, such as types of tumblers, the various grit sizes, and the characteristics of the various polish powders. I read it after only a couple of weeks of my own tumbling venture and found it directly relevant, immediately useful, and the best I have come across.

(See the review from “Rock and Gem Magazine”, which agrees with me.)    

The Rock Tumblers…

An internet search for rock tumblers took me to the website of Rotorua Lapidary who advertised that they sold rock tumblers. So I drove over there one day and bought three machines – two Lortone Model 33B Tumblers (each of which has two 3-pound rubber barrels) and one  Lortone Model 45C Tumbler (which has a 4-pound barrel). 

DSC08553
Two Lortone 33B Tumblers (with two 3-lb barrels each)

DSC08571
A Lortone 45C Tumbler (with one 4-lb barrel)

I had to guess what might turn out to be appropriate for us – I thought that Petra and I could each keep one of the 33B tumblers busy, and there is the flexibility of the two barrels – and we could share the larger one. Each 3-pound barrel is about 10 cms deep and 10 cms in diameter. The 4-pound barrel is 9 cms deep and 15 cms in diameter. The “pounds” refer to the weight of the load of stones that can be placed in them – three pounds is 1.33 kgs and four pounds is 1.8 kgs.

DSC08551
Three 3-lb barrels

DSC08552
The 4lb barrel

Colin Simmons of Rotorua Lapidary told me that he started rock tumbling in 1966. He opened his shop in Rotorua in 1981 and runs it with his wife Bev. He happily spent a long time with me, answering my questions about rock tumbling and offering advice based on his extensive experience. I am very grateful for the help he provided. Along with the tumblers I bought three grades of silicon carbide grit (100, 220 and 320), tin oxide polish powder (two grades – the “pre-polish” and the “pro-polish”), and plastic pellets (which are used to cushion the tumbling stones once they get more rounded or to make up a load if there’s not enough stones for the barrel). I was now ready to set up a small stone tumbling operation!